Responsible research

This is a mind map of the Research Ethics for Doctoral Students course. The map is organised as a tree, but in reality things are more interwined (something about "research security" can also fall under "legal compliance"). The numbers in parenthesis correspond to a section of the ethics course MOOC. What is not covered by the ethics course can be provided as external links. Missing bits are being added to a new version of the course. Some links are still missing.

Research support triage checklist

Twelve questions to ask a researcher. If the answer is yes or unsure, look at the hints and flag the case for the right specialist.

Partners and productsDataPeople and healthTechnology and securityEthics
  1. 1 Partners and products

    Is this basic research, applied research or work with a company?

    What to look for

    Is a company funding the research or involved in decisions? Who owns the results? Will the results be used commercially? More than one category can apply.

  2. 2 Data

    Are they using existing healthcare or social welfare data?

    What to look for

    Patient records, hospital data, health registers, Kanta data or biobank samples/data. Ask where the data comes from and whether it was collected for another purpose. Not all health data fall under the Secondary Use Act.

  3. 3 Data

    Is there sensitive personal data?

    What to look for

    Health, genetic data, biometrics used to identify people, ethnicity, religion, political opinions, sexual orientation, etc. Criminal records also need special attention.

  4. 4 Data

    Is there any other personal data?

    What to look for

    Interviews, recordings, photographs, student data, IP addresses, online activity, location data, pseudonymised data. Can a person be identified, even indirectly?

  5. 5 People and health

    Are people participating in the research? Does any TENK 4.2(a–f) condition apply?

    What to look for

    For non-medical human research, check:

    1. a) no normal informed consent
    2. b) intervention in physical integrity
    3. c) children under 15 without the specified parental consent/information
    4. d) exceptionally strong stimuli
    5. e) risk of unusually serious mental harm
    6. f) safety risks to participants, researchers or people close to them

    Any one may require prior ethics review.

  6. 6 People and health

    Is this medical research, or are they testing something on humans?

    What to look for

    Clinical trials, medicines, medical devices, diagnostic methods, medical interventions, human tissues or samples. Check whether medical ethics review, permissions or other approvals are required.

  7. 7 Technology and security

    Are they developing or using AI for something that could be high-risk or prohibited?

    What to look for

    AI assessing students, job applicants or employees; biometric identification; emotion recognition; manipulation; surveillance; decisions affecting people's rights or safety. Even in basic research, check whether the scientific-research exclusion applies, particularly for real-world testing or operational use.

  8. 8 Technology and security

    Could export controls, sanctions or dual-use rules apply?

    What to look for

    Military or defence applications, encryption, advanced electronics, quantum technology, drones, certain biotechnology or other controlled technologies. Also check foreign collaborators and access to controlled software or technical information from abroad.

  9. 9 Technology and security

    Are they working with hazardous or otherwise regulated materials or technologies?

    What to look for

    Animal experiments, GMOs, hazardous chemicals, radiation, dangerous biological agents, environmental releases or high-risk laboratory work. Check whether special permissions or safety assessments are needed.

  10. 10 Data

    Are they sharing data, software or technology with others?

    What to look for

    External companies, cloud services, AI services, foreign partners, shared research infrastructures. Is the data personal, confidential, copyrighted, licensed or export-controlled? Check who receives access and from where.

  11. 11 Ethics

    Could the research cause harm or raise other ethical concerns?

    What to look for

    Vulnerable participants, discrimination, surveillance, harmful uses of results, environmental damage, sensitive international research, human embryos, misuse of AI or other technologies. Ethical concerns can arise even when TENK review is not mandatory.

  12. 12 Partners and products

    Will the results become a product, service or something used outside the research project?

    What to look for

    Research software given to external users, AI systems making real decisions, medical devices, spin-outs, licensed technologies or commercial products. Legal requirements can change when something leaves the research environment.